22 Unique and Creative Neighbor Christmas Gift Ideas

This post may contain affiliate links. Please visit my disclosure policy for more information.

Spread holiday cheer with these unique and creative Christmas neighbor gift ideas! From homemade treats to practical goodies, find the perfect way to show your neighbors you care this season.”

A kitchen towel, hot drink cups, tortilla chips, salsa, potpourri, and drink coasters on table.

The holiday season is the perfect time to spread cheer and show appreciation to those around you, including your neighbors!

Whether you’re looking to start a new tradition or simply brighten someone’s day, a thoughtful gift can go a long way. But if you’re tired of the same old cookies and candles, don’t worry—I’ve got you covered.

Thankfully I’ve got some pretty creative neighbors who give awesome gifts every year! The following unique and creative ideas are sure to bring a smile to every doorstep this season!

Neighbor Christmas Gift Ideas

Bag of tortilla chips and salsa on table next to bows and ribbons.

A package of beef jerky with a tag that says "we don't mean to be cheesy, but thanks for not being jerks."

Natural Holiday Potpourri – Combine dried orange slices, cinnamon sticks, cloves, and star anise in a clear bag or jar. Attach instructions: “Simmer on the stove for a home full of holiday cheer!”
Hot Cocoa To Go – Pack hot cocoa mix, cups, and holders in a bag with a tag: “Just add hot water and a little Christmas magic!”
Holiday Kitchen Towels – Practical and festive, these towels add a cheerful touch to any kitchen while being something your neighbors will actually use.
Chips and Salsa – A savory alternative to sweet treats, this crowd-pleasing combo is perfect for holiday snacking or casual gatherings.
DIY Drink Coaster – Thoughtful and customizable, these handmade coasters are both functional and a lasting reminder of your holiday cheer.
Beef Jerky and Cheese – I thought this tag was so creative “Sorry this is cheesy, but thanks for not being jerks!”

Other Ideas

1. Cozy & Warm Theme

Socks with tag that says: For cold winter nights, we're sending cozy delights!

“Warm Wishes” Hot Cocoa Basket
Include gourmet hot chocolate mix, mini marshmallows, peppermint sticks, and a festive mug. Add a cute tag that says “Warm wishes to our wonderful neighbors!”
DIY Blanket Scarf or Cozy Socks
Pair with a tag: “For cold winter nights, we’re sending cozy delights!”

2. Homemade Delights

Jars of honey with honey dipper and tag that reads: A little something to sweeten your holiday!

Infused Olive Oil or Honey
Add herbs like rosemary or garlic for olive oil or cinnamon sticks for honey. A tag could say: “A little something to sweeten up your holidays.”
Christmas Breakfast Kit
Include pancake mix in a jar, maple syrup, and a small bottle of homemade hot cocoa mix. Tag: “Enjoy a relaxing Christmas morning on us!”

3. Personalized Touches

Stamps and envelopes on table with words that read: sending you a stamp of appreciation this holiday season.

Custom Address Stamps
Order personalized stamps with your neighbor’s address, packaged with ink and a tag: “Sending you a stamp of appreciation this holiday season!”
Family Name Ornaments
Handcraft or order wooden ornaments with their family name or individual names.
Photo Gift with Holiday Frame
Snap a photo of their house with festive lights or use a cute neighborhood photo and pair it with a lovely holiday frame.

4. Fun & Festive Surprises

Small jar of jam with bow and tag that reads: sometimes the smallest gifts bring the biggest joy!

“Reindeer Food” Snack Mix
Combine pretzels, red and green M&Ms, popcorn, and chocolate-covered nuts in a cute bag with a label: “Reindeer treats for a merry neighborhood feast!”
Elf-Sized Neighbor Gifts
Make tiny gifts like mini jams, little candles, or tea samples. Include a note: “Sometimes the smallest gifts bring the biggest joy!”
DIY S’mores Kits
Pack graham crackers, chocolate bars, and marshmallows in a festive bag with a tag: “Wishing you s’more joy this Christmas!”

5. Low-Tox and Practical Gifts

Jars of cleaner with a tag the reads: a little holiday sparkle for your home.

Homemade Cleaning Spray
Make an all-natural holiday-scented spray with water, vinegar, and essential oils (pine, orange, and clove). Add a tag: “A little holiday sparkle for your home!”
Eco-Friendly Wrap Set
Include reusable beeswax wraps, twine, and brown craft paper for sustainable holiday gift-wrapping.

6. Budget-Friendly & Charming

Pinecones on table with tag that reads: for warm fires and cozy nights this holiday season.

Christmas Light Care Kit
Include extra lightbulbs, clips, and a small card that says: “Helping you keep the glow alive!”
Pinecone Fire Starters
Dip pinecones in wax and sprinkle with glitter. Pair with a tag: “For warm fires and cozy nights this holiday season!”

7. Fun for Families

Bingo cards on red table with die and text that reads: family game night courtesy of Santa's workshop.

Holiday Bingo Kits
Include printed Bingo cards, markers, and candy. Add a tag: “Family game night, courtesy of Santa’s workshop!”
Cookie Decorating Kit
Provide baked cookies, frosting, and sprinkles for an easy holiday activity.